I have studied many timesSpoon River Anthology is an interesting collection of poems where each selection is a statement made by a dead person. Edgar Lee Masters found the inspiration for these epitaphs while walking around in a cemetery of his native Lewistown, Illinois, on the banks of the Spoon River. In English class the other day, we analyzed this particular poem, "George Gray", as a representation of the utmost metaphorical expression, but it also embodies the stark realities of living. The narrator, presumably Mr. Gray, seems remorseful over the results of his life. He regrets his passive existence and his reluctance to stretch his limits and go the distance. He describes the sailboat that adorns his tombstone and feels it does not symbolize the peace of his death but rather the stillness of his life. And then, he addresses the age-old question of finding the purpose of life. The sailboat serves as a metaphor for his potential (living life without inhibitions) and the actuality (not taking charge or moving forward).
The marble which was chiseled for me--
A boat with a furled sail at rest in a harbor.
In truth it pictures not my destination
But my life.
For love was offered me and I shrank from its disillusionment;
Sorrow knocked at my door, but I was afraid;
Ambition called to me, but I dreaded the chances.
Yet all the while I hungered for meaning in my life.
And now I know that we must lift the sail
And catch the winds of destiny
Wherever they drive the boat.
To put meaning in one's life may end in madness,
But life without meaning is the torture
Of restlessness and vague desire--
It is a boat longing for the sea and yet afraid.
~From Spoon River Anthology, by Edgar Lee Masters
This poem struck me because despite its short length, it conveys so much about a theme that all humanity shares: finding the meaning of life. We are all determined to discover the answer to this timeless dilemma. It worries us but guides us in our endeavors. Without that question, it leaves us with no direction, no sense of purpose in life, no reason to persevere. But to grasp that question sometimes requires the inner demons to unleash. It drives us to all kinds of places and states of mind. It scars us emotionally or even physically. It turns some of us into maddening fury and incredible suffering. Essentially, there is a fine line between enjoying the struggles and letting them completely consume us and weaken the spirit.
Life needs movement and progress. Sometimes, fate controls all, but other times, we need to be the enablers, the forces that shake the world. Being passive is simply not an option. But, when do you step out in the open, and when do you hold yourself back? We will always have regrets of not allowing ourselves to move away from familiar things, but how do you overcome them? How can they not affect your choices?
Life without meaning, life without an enigma to solve, life without an unexpected journey; these cannot be. But there always must be limits, but where? What are the roadblocks we ultimately cannot topple? And, how do we find the true meaning of life? These are the endless inquiries of the human race.
5 comments:
I like your analysis of this poem very much. It sounds like a good writer's notebook entry... (for break)
I actually liked Billiards better, because it was less obvious, and had cool phrases, like "late of the jungle, wild and dim." This one doesn't really give me any intriguing images.
An excellent analysis. My favourite line:
"He describes the sailboat that adorns his tombstone and feels it does not symbolize the peace of his death but rather the stillness of his life."
I believe, your post sums up everything - our struggles, dilemmas, inhibitations, etc. They are all blessings in disguise.
I really enjoyed reading the poem.
i like this poem and your thoughts on it.
it scares me to think about the meaning of life. just like how space scares me too.
there's this theory that says (i think, i don't remember exactly) that once we discover the meaning of life and the reason for the universe and why it exists the way it does, the entire universe will end and reappear as the most bizarre and strange universe that we could ever imagine. and then there's another theory that says that this has already happened.
maybe the meaning of life has always been to give life meaning. everyday we question ourselves and why we did or do certain things, and we search for explanations, so maybe the whole searching-for-yourself thing is also the finding-yourself part too.
this is why this scares me. because nothing and everything can make sense at the same time.
Kibberon,
I like how you put it:
"maybe the meaning of life has always been to give life meaning."
Maria: Billiards was interesting too. Like you said, the metaphor was less obvious, but just as pessimistic, and it reflects the flaws of humanity and society.
Zany: They are definitely "blessings in disguise". On one end, they guide us through our life's journey, but on the flip side, they cause so much trepidation and turmoil.
Kibberon: I agree with Zany on your excellent analysis. It is scary indeed how much life depends on making sense of things. When we feel secure and happy, we understand ourselves, but when we don't comprehend things, it makes everything all the more difficult.
Post a Comment